Not legal or accounting advice. The numbers below are made-up examples to show the math, not market rates. Run your own deal past your attorney and accountant.
Some landlords, especially in shopping centers, food halls, hotels, and mixed-use developments, will ask for percentage rent: a base rent plus a share of your sales above a certain level. Sometimes they offer it as a deal sweetener ("lower base rent, and we only win if you win"). Sometimes it's just stacked on top.
Either way, it means the landlord is now a silent partner in your top line. That can be fair. But how it's written decides whether it costs you a little in a great year or a lot in an average one.
The basic structure
Most percentage rent clauses have three parts:
- Base rent: the fixed rent you pay no matter what.
- A breakpoint: the sales level above which percentage rent kicks in.
- A percentage: the share of sales above the breakpoint that you pay as extra rent.
Some deals skip base rent entirely and charge only a percentage of sales (sometimes with a minimum). Those are more common in food halls, airports, stadiums, and licensed or concession arrangements.
Natural vs. artificial breakpoints
Natural breakpoint
The natural breakpoint is the sales level where the percentage times your sales equals your base rent:
Natural breakpoint = Annual base rent ÷ Percentage rate
Hypothetical example: base rent is $120,000 a year and the rate is 6%. $120,000 ÷ 0.06 = $2,000,000 natural breakpoint.
If your annual gross sales are $2,300,000, you owe 6% on the $300,000 above the breakpoint: $300,000 × 0.06 = $18,000 in percentage rent, on top of the $120,000 base.
The logic: below the breakpoint, the landlord is already getting at least the percentage through base rent.
Artificial breakpoint
An artificial breakpoint is any number the parties negotiate instead. A lower artificial breakpoint means you start paying sooner. A higher one is better for you.
Same hypothetical with a $1,500,000 artificial breakpoint: on $2,300,000 in sales you'd pay 6% on $800,000 = $48,000 in percentage rent. Same base rent, same rate, and a much bigger check.
Watch for this: when base rent goes up each year but the breakpoint stays flat, a "natural" breakpoint quietly becomes a low artificial one. If you agree to a natural breakpoint, make sure it resets every time base rent changes.
"Gross sales": the definition that matters most
The percentage gets attention. The definition of gross sales decides the bill. Landlords' forms usually start broad. Push to exclude:
- Sales tax and other taxes collected for the government
- Tips, gratuities, and service charges paid to staff
- Refunds, voids, comps, and discounts (you never actually received the money)
- Employee meals and promotional or comped food
- Gift card and gift certificate sales until redeemed (and never twice)
- Third-party delivery commissions and fees. If an app takes a cut, count only what you net, or exclude delivery and off-premises sales entirely. Agree on this upfront.
- Catering and off-site sales prepared or delivered elsewhere
- Credit card processing fees (landlords often resist this one, but ask)
- Sales of equipment, fixtures, or the business itself
- Bad debt and returned checks
- Revenue from other locations, including online orders fulfilled from another kitchen
If your concept is delivery-heavy, sales from your space through apps and your own website are a big deal. Spell out how those orders are counted.
Reporting and audits
Percentage rent comes with reporting obligations. Read them closely:
- What you report and when (monthly or annual sales statements, often certified by an officer or a CPA)
- How percentage rent is paid: monthly against the annual breakpoint (prorated), or annually after year-end. Annual reconciliation is usually easier on cash flow.
- Audit rights: the landlord can audit your books. Make sure audits are limited in frequency and lookback period, and that you only pay for the audit if there's a material underreport (the threshold is negotiable).
- Confidentiality: your sales numbers should be kept confidential except as needed for the landlord's lenders, buyers, and advisors.
- Tie to your POS: if your POS data is the record, agree on which report counts.
Clauses that travel with percentage rent
Percentage rent rarely shows up alone. Look for these:
Radius restriction
The landlord may prohibit you from opening another location within a set distance, since that location could pull sales away from this one. Keep it short in distance and duration. Exclude locations you already operate, delivery-only kitchens, and catering. Make the remedy something other than "default the lease," such as counting a share of the other store's sales.
Operating covenant
If the landlord's income depends on your sales, they may require you to stay open certain hours or days. Make sure you can close for renovations, holidays, staffing emergencies, and casualty without being in default.
Kick-out (sales-based termination)
Some tenants negotiate a right to terminate if sales don't hit a set level by a certain year. Some landlords want the same right if your sales are low. If the landlord has a kick-out, try to make it mutual and make sure it reimburses your unamortized buildout costs.
Co-tenancy (in shopping centers)
If your traffic depends on an anchor tenant or a minimum occupancy level, a co-tenancy clause can reduce your rent if those disappear.
When percentage rent can actually work for you
Percentage rent isn't automatically bad. It can make sense when:
- The landlord lowers base rent meaningfully in exchange, so you pay less in a slow year
- The breakpoint is high (natural and resetting, or artificially above natural)
- Gross sales are defined tightly, with the exclusions above
- The landlord brings real value: a destination location, marketing, foot traffic, a food hall's built-in crowd
It's usually a bad trade when the base rent is full market and the breakpoint is low, which just gives away your upside.
Running the numbers before you sign
Before you agree, have your accountant build a simple model:
- Projected annual sales at a slow, expected, and strong year
- Base rent, escalations, and additional rent: your proportionate share of real estate tax increases over the base year, plus CAM and utilities
- Percentage rent at each sales level, using the actual gross sales definition from the draft lease
- Total occupancy cost as a share of sales at each level
If total occupancy cost becomes unworkable in your expected case, the clause needs to change, or the deal does.
Questions to ask the landlord
- Is the breakpoint natural or artificial? Does it reset when base rent changes?
- What exactly is excluded from gross sales? Can we add delivery commissions, tips, and comps?
- How often and how far back can you audit? Who pays?
- Is there a radius restriction? How far, and for how long?
- Is there an operating covenant? What hours?
- Will you trade lower base rent for percentage rent?
Get the free checklist: The NYC Restaurant Lease Red-Flag Checklist includes the full gross-sales exclusion list plus everything else to check before you sign. Get it here →
This article is general information, not legal, tax, or accounting advice, and all dollar figures are hypothetical examples. Talk to your attorney and accountant before signing. Eligible NYC small businesses can get free lease help through the City's Commercial Lease Assistance Program.
Get the free NYC Restaurant Lease Red-Flag Checklist
80+ things to check before you sign a letter of intent or a lease in New York City, from the C of O and venting to guaranties, tax escalations, and assignment rights.
One email with the checklist, then occasional NYC restaurant leasing notes. Unsubscribe anytime. Privacy.