Not legal, tax, or accounting advice. This is a broker's plain-English walkthrough of the NYC Department of Finance's published rules. All dollar examples are made up to show the math, not market rents. Have your accountant confirm your own numbers and filing obligations. The official sources are DOF's Commercial Rent Tax page and the Form CR-A instructions.

If you're opening a restaurant in Manhattan below 96th Street, there's a tax most first-time operators have never heard of until their accountant mentions it: the Commercial Rent Tax. It's a City tax on the rent you pay, it lands on the tenant, not the landlord, and in the right rent range it adds a meaningful slice to your occupancy cost.

The good news is that a lot of smaller restaurants owe little or nothing because of two credits. The bad news is that you need to know where you fall before you agree on a rent, because CRT moves the number you can actually afford.

Who has to pay it

According to the Department of Finance, you're subject to CRT if all of these are true:

  • You rent space for a business or other commercial activity in Manhattan, south of the center line of 96th Street;
  • Your annual or annualized rent is at least $250,000. DOF measures this using your base rent before the 35% reduction described below; and
  • You don't fall into one of the exemptions.

The tax is on the tenant, which DOF defines broadly as anyone paying rent as a lessee, sub-lessee, licensee, or concessionaire. A license agreement in a food hall can count.

Not subject: above 96th Street and the outer boroughs

DOF's instructions state that CRT has been repealed for premises north of the center line of 96th Street in Manhattan and in the Bronx, Brooklyn, Queens, and Staten Island (CR-A instructions). If you're comparing a space on the Upper West Side at 97th Street to one at 94th, or Williamsburg to the West Village, CRT is a real line-item difference between those deals.

Other exemptions worth knowing

DOF lists several exemptions. These are the ones that can come up for restaurants:

  • Tenants in the World Trade Center Area (a specific set of blocks DOF defines by street boundaries).
  • Premises used for retail sales inside the Commercial Revitalization Program abatement zone in Lower Manhattan. Ask your accountant whether a restaurant qualifies as "retail sales" for this purpose before you count on it.
  • Renting premises for 14 days or less in a tax year (pop-ups).

How the tax is calculated

The statutory rate is 6% of base rent, but every taxpayer gets a 35% base rent reduction first. That makes the effective rate 3.9% of base rent (DOF).

6% × (100% − 35%) = 3.9%

Two credits can then reduce the tax.

1. The phase-in credit: $250,000 to $300,000

If your annualized base rent (before the 35% reduction) is at least $250,000 but less than $300,000, you get a credit that phases the tax in. Per the worksheet on Form CR-A, for a full 12-month year:

Credit = Tax × ($300,000 − your base rent) ÷ $50,000

So right at $250,000 the credit wipes out the whole tax. At $275,000 it cuts it in half. At $300,000 and up there's no phase-in credit.

2. The Small Business Tax Credit

This is the big one for independent restaurants. Per DOF's CR-A instructions:

  • If your "total income" is $5,000,000 or less and your annual base rent (before the 35% reduction) is less than $500,000, the credit effectively exempts you. You owe nothing.
  • There are two separate phase-outs, and they multiply together:
    • Income factor: 1 if total income is $5M or less. Between $5M and $10M it's ($10,000,000 − total income) ÷ $5,000,000.
    • Rent factor: 1 if base rent is under $500,000. Between $500,000 and $550,000 it's ($550,000 − base rent) ÷ $50,000.
    • Credit = (tax − any phase-in credit) × income factor × rent factor.
  • Total income of $10M or more, or base rent of $550,000 or more, gets no small business credit.

So a partial credit is available if your income is between $5M and $10M (with rent under $550K), or if your rent is between $500K and $550K (with income under $10M). You don't need both.

"Total income" is not your sales

This trips people up. DOF defines total income as the figure reported on your federal return (for example, Form 1120 line 11, 1120-S line 6, or 1065 line 8) for the tax year before the CRT period: gross receipts minus returns and allowances, minus cost of goods sold, plus other income items like interest, dividends, and gross rents (DOF). For a restaurant, total income is roughly your sales minus food and beverage cost, plus any other income. Ask your accountant to pull the actual number from your return, or to project it for a new concept.

What counts as "rent" (it's more than your base rent)

This is the part most operators miss. For CRT, DOF treats rent as everything you pay for the use or occupancy of the space, including any payment you make on the landlord's behalf for real estate taxes, water and sewer charges, or other expenses (including insurance) normally payable by a landlord. Expenses for the improvement, repair, or maintenance of your own premises are excluded (CR-A instructions).

In practice:

  • Your real estate tax escalation payments to the landlord count as rent for CRT.
  • Water and sewer charges you pay the landlord count.
  • Your own repairs and maintenance in the space don't.

Base rent for CRT is that rent, minus any rent you collect from a subtenant of part of the premises. If you rent for less than a full year, it's annualized as if you'd paid at the same rate all year.

Percentage rent: if part of your rent is a percentage of sales, DOF counts the actual percentage of gross receipts due the landlord, but not more than 15% of gross receipts (CR-A instructions). If you have percentage rent, it goes into the CRT number too. See our Percentage Rent Explained guide.

Two locations in one building are added together and treated as one premises.

Worked examples (illustrative only)

All figures below are hypothetical, chosen to show the math. "Rent" means CRT base rent before the 35% reduction, including pass-throughs like real estate tax escalations paid to the landlord, for a full 12-month year.

Scenario CRT rent Total income Tax at 3.9% Credits Estimated CRT owed
A. Small café $240,000 any — Below $250K threshold $0 (but a return may still be required, see filing below)
B. Phase-in zone, larger operator $275,000 $12M $10,725 Phase-in: $10,725 × ($25,000 ÷ $50,000) = $5,362.50; no small business credit (income ≥ $10M) $5,362.50
C. Typical independent $400,000 $4M $15,600 Small business credit, factors 1 × 1 = $15,600 $0
D. Busier independent $400,000 $8M $15,600 Income factor ($10M − $8M) ÷ $5M = 0.40, so credit = $6,240 $9,360
E. Big space, modest income $525,000 $4M $20,475 Rent factor ($550K − $525K) ÷ $50K = 0.50, so credit = $10,237.50 $10,237.50
F. Flagship $600,000 any $23,400 None (rent ≥ $550K) $23,400 (about $1,950/month)

Watch the threshold creep

Because pass-throughs count as rent, your CRT number can cross a threshold even if your base rent doesn't change. Hypothetical: base rent of $490,000 plus $15,000 a year in real estate tax escalations paid to the landlord = $505,000 CRT rent. That crosses $500,000, so the rent factor drops to ($550,000 − $505,000) ÷ $50,000 = 0.90. With total income under $5M, tax of $19,695 less a $17,725.50 credit leaves $1,969.50 owed, where at $499,000 you'd have owed nothing. Annual rent bumps and tax escalations push you up over the years, so model future years too, not just year one.

How CRT changes what rent you can afford

Treat CRT as part of occupancy cost, just like CAM and real estate taxes. If you're fully taxable (example F territory), every dollar of rent really costs you about $1.039.

Hypothetical: say your pro forma says the most you can spend on rent plus CRT is $600,000 a year, and you're above the credit ranges. The most rent you can afford is:

$600,000 ÷ 1.039 ≈ $577,478 a year

That's roughly $22,500 a year less rent than you thought you could pay, before you've even looked at the CRT treatment of your tax escalations.

If you're near a threshold, the math is lumpier:

  • Near $250K–$300K or $500K–$550K, a small change in rent can mean a big change in tax. Know which side of the line you're on.
  • If your total income is near $5M or $10M, a strong sales year can reduce next year's credit. The credit uses the prior tax year's federal return.

Factoring CRT into your LOI and budget

Things I'd do on any deal below 96th Street:

  1. Ask whether the space is in the CRT zone (it is if it's in Manhattan south of the center line of 96th Street) and whether any special exemption area applies. Don't assume either way near the WTC Area or in Lower Manhattan.
  2. Calculate your CRT rent, not just base rent. Add expected real estate tax escalations, water and sewer, and anything else you pay the landlord that a landlord normally pays. Include percentage rent if there is any.
  3. Project your total income with your accountant for the credit test.
  4. Put CRT in your budget as its own line under occupancy cost, for every year of the term, using the rent steps.
  5. Negotiate with the number in mind. CRT is your tax, and landlords don't usually absorb it. But knowing it lets you justify your rent offer, or find a rent level that keeps you under $500,000 or $250,000. For example, trading a slightly lower base rent for a longer free-rent period can keep the annualized number down. Confirm with your accountant how DOF would treat any structure before you rely on it.
  6. Compare across the 96th Street line and the boroughs. When two spaces are otherwise close, CRT can be a deciding factor.

Filing basics (as DOF states them)

Per DOF's CRT page and the CR-A and CR-Q instructions:

  • Tax year: June 1 through May 31.
  • Annual return (Form CR-A): due June 20 for the prior June–May year.
  • Quarterly returns (Form CR-Q): every tenant subject to tax files quarterly, for periods ending August 31, November 30, and the end of February, due within 20 days, which DOF lists as September 20, December 20, and March 20.
  • Filing even if you owe nothing: a tenant below the $250,000 threshold must still file an annual return if annual or annualized gross rent for any premises is more than $200,000, or if it receives more than $200,000 in rent from a subtenant. At $200,000 or less (and no subtenant rent over $200,000), no annual return is required.
  • Registration and e-filing: DOF directs taxpayers to register for electronic filing and file and pay through NYC e-Services. Paper forms are also available on DOF's site.
  • Late filing: DOF assesses a late-filing penalty of 5% of the tax per month, up to 25%, plus interest, unless there's reasonable cause.
  • If you close: the tax is due immediately, and a final annual return is due within 20 days of ceasing business. If you keep paying rent after you close, you keep filing.
  • Records: keep your leases for three years after they expire and other CRT records for three years after filing.

Your accountant should handle the actual filings. You just need to know the obligation exists before you sign, so it's in your budget.

The bottom line

In Manhattan below 96th Street, CRT is part of your rent, whether or not it's in your lease. Many smaller independents end up owing nothing thanks to the small business credit. But once your CRT rent (including tax escalations and other pass-throughs) climbs past $500,000, or your total income passes $5 million, it starts to bite. At $550,000 and up it's a straight 3.9%. Run the numbers for every year of the term before you put a rent number in your LOI.


Get the free checklist: The NYC Restaurant Lease Red-Flag Checklist includes CRT plus 80+ other things to check before you sign. Get it here →

This article is general information based on NYC Department of Finance publications as of November 2026. It is not legal, tax, or accounting advice and doesn't create a professional relationship. Tax rules, forms, and thresholds can change; confirm current requirements with DOF and your accountant. Eligible NYC small businesses can get free lease help through the City's Commercial Lease Assistance Program.